Railways NTPC (Technical Ability) Power and Control System Control System

Control System

Category : Railways

Control System

 

CONTROL SYSTEM

It is an arrangement of different physical components in such a way that we get the desired output from the input.

 

Classification of Control System

  • Open Loop Control System: It is a system which has no feedback & its output has no effect on control action, as shown in fig.

 

 

For example: traffic light, tap of water etc.

Advantages: These systems are simple in construction & design; economic in nature; easy from the maintenance point of view, have high stability & are convenient to use when the output is difficult to measure.

Disadvantages: These systems are not accurate & reliable as the accuracy depends on the calibration of the inputs & their operation is affected due to the presence of non-linearities in the elements.

  • Closed Loop System: It is a system which takes feedback & its output has an effect on the control action through that feedback, as shown in fig.

For example A. C., humans etc.

Advantages: These systems have high accuracy: system errors can be modified as these systems can sense environmental changes as well as internal disturbances. They also have less reduced effects of non-linearities, and have high bandwidth

Disadvantages: These systems are complicated to construct, and are costly & unstable in nature.

 

PRINCIPLE OF FEEDBACK

In the open loop system, there is no feedback path, but this feedback path exists in a closed loop system. So, in a closed loop system, the output will also depend on the feedback system. The purpose of feedback is to reduce the error which exists due to the difference in reference input and system output.

There are two types of feedback:

1)   Positive feedback

2)   Negative feedback

Positive feedback: When the output which is fed as an input to the system, is in the same phase with the input, then this feedback increases the input or it is added to the input. The positive feedback is used in oscillator circuits.

For positive feedback, error signal \[=r(t)+c(t)\]

 

 

Negative feedback: When the output which is fed as an input to the system, is in a completely opposite phase to the input, then this feedback reduces the input or is subtracted from the input. This feedback helps in stabilizing the gain of the amplifier. Negative feedback is used in amplifier circuits.

For negative feedback, error signal =r (t) - c (t)

 

 

Effects of Feedback:

  • Gain is reduced by a factor & there is reduction of parameter variation by a factor of {1 + G(s) H(s)}.
  • There is improvement in sensitivity & a reduction in stability, i.e. the system might become unstable.
  • Feedback can reduce the effects of noise & disturbance on the system's performance; there by making the system more accurate.


BLOCK DIAGRAM REDUDCTION TECHNIQUES:

 

Manipulation

Original Block diagram

Equivalent Block diagram

Equation

Blocks in cacade

\[A=({{G}_{1}}{{G}_{2}})B\]

Blocks in parallel

\[A=({{G}_{1}}+{{G}_{2}})B\]

Shifting take-off point at the back of the block

\[A=GB\,\,or\,\,B\,=A/G\]

Shifting take-off point at the front of the block

\[A=GB\]

Shifting summing point at the front of the block

\[A=G{{B}_{1}}-{{B}_{2}}\]

Shifting summing point at the back of the block

\[{{E}_{2}}=G({{B}_{1}}-{{B}_{2}})\]

 

Rules for Drawing SFG

 

  • The signal travels along a branch in the direction of an arrow from input node to output node.
  • The input signal is multiplied by the transmittance to obtain the output signal.
  • Input signal at a node is the sum of all signals entering at that node.
  • Equation of each node is written as shown in fig.

 

 

Signal flow graph with one forward path and single isolated loop Fig.

At node \[{{x}_{2}},{{x}_{2}}=a{{x}_{1}}+c{{x}_{3}}\]

At node \[{{x}_{3}},{{x}_{3}}=b{{x}_{2}}\]

 

TRANSFER FUNCTIONS

  • The relation between input & output is represented by a block diagram shown in fig. Thus, the transfer function is basically the ratio of output quantity to input quantity, given as

\[G(s)=\frac{C(s)}{R(s)}\,\,or\,\,C(s)=G(s)R(s)\]

 

Fig.

Suppose a transfer function of a linear control system is given by

\[G(s)=\frac{A(s)}{B(s)}=\frac{K(s-{{s}_{1}})(s-{{s}_{2}})(s-{{s}_{3}})....(s-{{s}_{n}})}{(s-{{s}_{a}})(s-{{s}_{b}})(s-{{s}_{c}})....(s-{{s}_{m}})}\]

where 'K' is the gain factor of transfer function.

Poles of transfer function: In above expression, ifs is put equal to\[{{s}_{a}},\,\,{{s}_{b}},\,\,{{s}_{c}}.....{{s}_{m}},\], then it is observed that the value of transfer function becomes infinite, thus\[{{s}_{a}},\,\,{{s}_{b}},\,\,{{s}_{c}}.....{{s}_{m}},\] are called poles of the transfer function; it is represented by X.

Zeros of transfer function: In above expression, ifs is put equal to\[{{s}_{1}},\,\,{{s}_{2}},\,\,{{s}_{3}}.....{{s}_{n}},\], then it is observed that the value of transfer function becomes zero, thus\[{{s}_{1}},\,\,{{s}_{2}},\,\,{{s}_{3}}.....{{s}_{n}},\]are called zeros of the transfer function; it is represented by 0.

  • Poles or zeros can either be real or complex
  • If the number of poles (n) is greater than the number of zeros (m), then the value of transfer fanction is found to be infinity for \[s=\infty \]
  • If the number of poles (n) is less than the number of zeros (m), then the value of transfer function is found to be zero

For \[s=\infty \]

  • Stability of any system depends only on the location of poles but not on the location of zeros.
  • If the poles are located in the left side of s-plane, then the system is stable, whereas if located on the right side of s plane, then the system is unstable.
  • As the pole approaches the origin, stability decreases & the poles which are closer to the origin are called dominant poles.

 

STEADY STATE ERRORS

  • A system has a steady state error when the actual output during steady states deviates from the desired output. This error should be as low as possible to increase the accuracy of the system.
  • In a closed loop control system, the magnitude of steady state error depends on its open loop transfer function i.e.

G (s) H (s) of the system, which is given by

\[G\,\,(s)H\,\,(s)=\frac{K\,\,(1+s{{T}_{a}})\,\,(1+s{{T}_{b}}).....}{{{s}^{N}}(1+{{s}^{T}}_{1})\,\,(1+s{{T}_{2}})....}\]

where K is the forward path gain, N is the number of poles  at the origin and

\[\left. \begin{matrix}

   -\frac{1}{{{T}_{a}}},\,\,-\frac{1}{{{T}_{b}}}......are\,\,zeros  \\

   -\frac{1}{{{T}_{1}}},\,\,-\frac{1}{{{T}_{2}}}......are\,\,poles  \\

\end{matrix} \right\}\]

  • When N = 0, system is called as type 0 system.
  • When N = 1, system is called as type 1 system.
  • When N = 2, system is called as type 2 system.

When N = N, system is called as type N system.

 

              

  • As shown in fig., the error E(s) & input R(s) are related to each other as:

\[\frac{E\,\,(s)}{R\,\,(s)}=\frac{1}{1+G\,\,(s)\,\,H\,\,(s)}\]

  • Final value theorem is given by

If          \[f(t)\xrightarrow{laplace\,\,transform}F\,\,(s)\]

then      \[\underset{t\to \infty }{\mathop{lim}}\,\,\,f(t)=\underset{s\to 0}{\mathop{lim}}\,F(s)\]

  • Now, on applying the final value theorem, the steady state error can be determined as:

\[{{e}_{ss}}=\underset{s\to 0}{\mathop{\lim }}\,\,\,sE(s)\,\,\underset{s\to 0}{\mathop{lim}}\,\,\,sR(s).\frac{1}{1+G(s)\,\,H(s)}\]

  • For step function or displacement function, R(s) = A/s (where A is a slope) & when unit step function is taken into consideration, R(s) = 1/s.
  • For ramp function or velocity function, R(s) =\[=A/{{s}^{2}}\]& when unit ramp function is considered, R(s)\[=1/{{s}^{2}}\]
  • For parabolic function or acceleration fanction,
  • R(s)\[=1/{{s}^{3}}\]& when unit parabolic function is considered, R(s)\[=1/{{s}^{3}}\]

 

TECHNIQUES USED TO CALCULATE STABILITY

  • Techniques used for this purpose are Routh-Hurwitz criterion. Root locus, Bode plot & Nyquist plot.

 

Routh–Hurwitz Criterion

  • It is a method where we determine the location of poles of a polynomial with constant real coefficients.
  • For applying this method, it is required that no powers of is in the characteristic equation should be absent otherwise the system confirms instability by inspection.
  • All roots of equation must lie in the left half of s-plane.
  • The difficulties while carrying Hurwitz Criterion occur when the first element in any single row of the Routh tabulation is zero, while the elements are not & when the elements in one row of Routh tabulation are all zero.

 

NYQUIST PATH OR NYQUIST CONTOUR

The overall transfer of a system is given by.

\[\frac{C(s)}{R(s)}=\frac{G(s)}{1+G(s)\,\,H(s)}\]

The characteristic equation is 1 + G(s) H(s) = 0

The main purpose in study the stability of the closed loop system is to determine whether the characteristic equation has any root in the right half of s-plane i.e. whether C(s)/R(s) has any pole in right half of s-plane.

For this purpose, we use a contour in s-plane which encloses the entire right half plane. This contour having the encirclement in clockwise direction and radius 'R' approaches infinity. This path or contour is known as Nyquist contour shown in fig. (a) If the system does not have any pole or zero at origin then the contour is shown in fig. (b).

 

 

 

GENERAL CONSTRUCTION RULES OF THE NYQUIST PATH

Consider the fig.

Path ab

\[s=j\omega \,\,0<\omega <{{\omega }_{0}}\]

(i)

Path bc

\[s=\underset{p\to 0}{\mathop{lime\,\,}}\,(j{{\omega }_{0}}+P{{e}^{j\theta }})-90{}^\circ \le \theta \le 90{}^\circ \]

(ii)

Path cd

\[s=j\omega \,\,{{\omega }_{0}}\le \omega \le \infty \]

(iii)

Path def

\[s=\underset{R\to \infty }{\mathop{lim}}\,{{\operatorname{Re}}^{j\theta }}-90{}^\circ \le \theta \le 90{}^\circ \]

(iv)

Path fg

\[s=j\omega -\infty <\omega <-{{\omega }_{0}}\]

(v)

Path gh

\[s=\underset{P\to 0}{\mathop{\lim \,\,}}\,(J{{\omega }_{0}}+P{{e}^{j\theta }})-90{}^\circ \le \theta \le 90{}^\circ \]

(vi)

Path hi

\[s=j\omega \,\,{{\omega }_{0}}\le \omega \le 0\]

(vii)

Path ija

\[s=\underset{P\to 0}{\mathop{lim}}\,P{{e}^{j\theta }}-90{}^\circ \le \theta \le 90{}^\circ \]

(viii)

 

Step 1: Check G(s) for poles on\[j\omega \]axis and at the origin

Step 2: Using \[e{{q}^{n}}\](i) to \[e{{q}^{n}}\](iii) sketch the image of the path \[a-d\]in the \[G\left( s \right)-\]plane. If there are no poles on\[j\omega \]axis equation (ii) need not be employed.

Step 3: Draw the mirror image about the real axis of the sketch resulting from step 2.

Step 4: Use \[e{{q}^{n}}\](iv) plot the image of path def. This path at infinity usually plot into a point in the \[G\left( s \right)-\]plane.

Step 5:  Use \[e{{q}^{n}}\](viii) plot the image of path ija (pole at origin)

Step 6: Connect all curves drawn into the previous steps.

 

BODE PLOT

  • It is used to draw the frequency response of an open loop

& a closed loop system. It is also called comer plot & asymptotic plot.

  • The representation of logarithm of \[|G\,\,(j\omega )|\]& phase angle of\[G(j\omega )\], both plotted against frequency in logarithmic scale & these plots are called Bode plots.
  • Here we determine gain margin & phase margin.
  • The gain margin is determined by:

\[G.M.=20\,\,{{\log }_{10}}\frac{1}{|G\,\,(J{{\omega }_{2}})\,\,H\,\,(j{{\omega }_{2}})|}\]

Where\[{{\omega }_{2}}\]of is the phase cross frequency where \[\angle G\,\,(j\omega )\,\,H\,\,(j\omega ){}^\circ \] line crosses the frequency axis.

  • When\[|G\,\,(j{{\omega }_{2}})\,\,H\,\,(J{{\omega }_{2}})|<1\], the G. M. in decibel comes out to be positive indicating a stable system.
  • When\[|G\,\,(j{{\omega }_{2}})\,\,H\,\,(J{{\omega }_{2}})|=1\], the G. M. in decibel comes out to be zero indicating a marginally stable system.
  • When\[|G\,\,(j{{\omega }_{2}})\,\,H\,\,(J{{\omega }_{2}})|<1\], the G.M. in decibel comes out to be negative indicating an unstable system.
  • The phase margin is given by:

\[P.M.=180{}^\circ +\angle G\,\,(j{{\omega }_{1}})\,\,H\,\,(j{{\omega }_{1}}){}^\circ \]

Where \[\angle G\,\,(j{{\omega }_{1}})\,\,H\,\,(j{{\omega }_{1}}){}^\circ \]is measured clockwise & \[{{\omega }_{1}}\]is the gain crossover frequency at which\[|G\,\,(j\omega )\,\,H\,\,(j\omega )\,\,H\,\,(j\omega )|\]crosses the frequency axis.

  • For a stable system, phase margin should be positive and the gain cross over frequency should be less than the phase cross over frequency.
  • For unstable systems: the gain cross over frequency > phase cross over frequency.
  • For marginally stable systems: the gain cross over frequency should be equal to the phase cross over frequency.

 

ROOT LOCUS

  • It is the graphical representation of the roots of the characteristic equation.
  • Given system is an undamped system, if roots of the characteristic equation lie on the imaginary axis i.e., real part=0.
  • Given system is an under damped system, if roots of the characteristic equation have an imaginary part with a negative real part.
  • The given system is a critically damped system, if roots are real & same.
  • Given system is an over damped system, if roots are real & different.

 

State Transistion Matrix

It is a matrix which statistics the linear homogeneous state equation.

It is given by\[\phi \,\,(t)={{L}_{-1}}[{{(sI-A)}^{-1}}]\]& is of the order: n\[\times \]n.

Properties of state transistion matrix:

  • \[\phi \,\,(0)=I\] where I is identity matrix
  • \[{{\phi }^{-1}}(t)=\phi (-t)\]
  • \[\phi \,\,({{t}_{2}}-{{t}_{1}})\,\,\phi \,\,({{t}_{1}}-{{t}_{0}})=\phi \,\,({{t}_{2}}-{{t}_{0}})\,\,for\,\,any\,\,{{t}_{0}},\,\,{{t}_{1}},\,\,{{t}_{2}}\]
  • \[{{[\phi \,\,(t)]}^{k}}=\phi \,\,(kt)\,\,for\,\,k\,\,=positive\,\,integer\]

 

CONTROLLABILITY OF LINEAR CONTROL SYSTEM

It is in relation to the transfer of a system from one state to another by appropriate input controls in a finite time.

For the system to be completely controllable, it is sufficient that the n\[\times \]nr matrix has a rank of n.

\[U=[B:AB:{{A}^{2}}B....{{A}^{n-1}}B]\]

Where U = Controllability test matrix which is n \[\times \] nr.

 

OBSERVABILITY OF LINEAR CONTROL SYSTEM:

  • It is a method of determining the state of a system by observing its output.
  • The matrix V is known as the observability test matrix of

\[n~\times np\]row matrix form & is given by

\[V=[{{C}^{T}}:{{A}^{T}}{{C}^{T}}:{{({{A}^{T}})}^{2}}{{C}^{T}}:....{{({{A}^{T}})}^{n-1}}{{C}^{T}}]\]

And controlling torque, \[{{T}_{c}}={{K}_{c}}\theta \]

At steady position of pointer, \[{{T}_{c}}={{T}_{d}}\]

And thus, \[\theta \propto {{I}^{2}}\]

  • Since, the deflection of the pointer is directly proportional to the square of the current, the scale of the electrodynamometer type instrument is not uniform.

The transfer function is in the form:

\[G\,\,(s)=\frac{K\omega _{n}^{2}}{{{s}^{2}}+2\xi {{\omega }_{n}}s+\omega _{n}^{2}},\]   \[\xi >0{{\omega }_{n}}>0\]

Here, K is called the DC gain, \[{{\omega }_{n}}\]is called the natural frequency, and\[\xi \]is called the damping ratio of the system. We will consider three case:

Case 1: \[\xi >1\]

This case is called the overdamped case.

\[{{\omega }_{d}}={{\omega }_{n}}\,\,\left( \xi -\sqrt{{{\xi }^{2}}-1} \right)\]

 

Case 2: \[\xi =1\]

This case is called the critically damped case.

 

Case 3: \[0<\xi <1\]

This case is called the underdamped case.

Maximum percent overshoot

\[{{M}_{P}}={{e}^{\frac{-\xi \pi }{\sqrt{1-{{\xi }^{2}}}}}}\]

 

Other Topics

Notes - Control System


You need to login to perform this action.
You will be redirected in 3 sec spinner